Compare network migration tools for firewalls, routers and switches. This page lines up Expedition, FortiConverter and Cisco FMT with NetConverter, which migrates and validates those configurations and leaves findings for engineer review.
Longer comparisons: Palo Alto Expedition, FortiConverter, Check Point SmartMove, Cisco FMT, and FireMon, Tufin and AlgoSec alternatives.
Each vendor tool targets its own platform. NetConverter adds deterministic checks with findings for engineer review.
Scored against Expedition’s own vendor matrix and four API use cases — not a NetConverter feature list. Cells are Live, Preview (code exists, not a productized path), or Missing. Updated 2026-09-21.
Expedition’s destination is always PAN-OS. We score collection and translation to PAN-OS separately.
| Expedition cell | Expedition | Collect | Translate to PAN-OS | Honest score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Check Point R80+ objects, security, NAT | Live | Live (collector + handoff) | Live (CP→PA jobs) | Live — zones still any; NAT placeholders |
| Check Point L3 + static routes | Live | Live (Gaia) | Live | Live |
| Check Point R75/R77 | Live | Missing | — | Wont — we are R80+ Management API |
| Check Point VPN | Empty in their matrix | Membership only | Missing | Missing |
| Cisco ASA objects, security, NAT, L3, routes | Live (8.2–9.6) | Live | Live | Live |
| Cisco ASA VPN | Live (their only VPN tick) | Preview | Not measured | Preview — not claimed as translated |
| FirePower (ASA syntax only) | Live | FMC file output. The hosted service does not log in to FMC | Preview | Ingest via Local handoff ZIP · emit FMC JSON (Preview) |
| FortiGate 4/5/6 | Live | FortiManager 1.3.0 — newer than theirs | Preview | FortiGate to PAN-OS, with engineer review |
| Juniper ScreenOS / Junos 11–12 | Live | Wont | Wont | Wont for this old Expedition source. Current JunOS router translation is a separate path, in the table below. |
| Panorama as source | Upload to a project | Live — running-config | Preview | Collect Live · conversion Preview |
| Expedition use case | Expedition | NetConverter today |
|---|---|---|
| 3rd-party vendor config → PAN-OS | Live | Live for Cisco ASA and Check Point R80+ (handoff). FortiGate → PAN-OS is supported, with engineer review. Current JunOS is not this cell. FMC is a file-output target and is accepted as a source through a NetConverter Local handoff ZIP. Strata Cloud Manager is supported on request, not in the self-service platform. |
| Remove unused objects + export XML | Live (filter → delete collection) | Preview — we detect unused on CP/Panorama; we do not yet delete and emit loadable XML |
| Bulk apply Security Profile Group | Live | Missing |
| List rules containing a subnet | Live | Preview — graph can; no one-click filter yet |
--running-config is complete by construction. Expedition’s “add device + upload” was a project file.Collectors are public on valeronlabs/netconverter-collectors.
Vendor tools vs NetConverter. Expedition cells above are the apples-to-apples; this table is the wider market view.
| Capability | Cisco FMT | PA Expedition | FortiConverter | NetConverter |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Destination vendors | FMC/FTD only | PAN-OS only | FortiGate only | PAN-OS XML/SET/Panorama, FortiGate, IOS-XE, JunOS, Aruba CX. Router and switch results stay in NEEDS REVIEW. FMC is file output; Strata Cloud Manager is supported on request, not in the self-service platform |
| Pre-deployment validation | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Deterministic checks, with findings for engineer review |
| Twice-NAT handling | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Single mapping |
| VPN migration | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Preview — gaps flagged; not claimed as a completed VPN translator |
| Dynamic routing | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Static routes Live (CP Gaia). Dynamic routing Preview — flagged, not a silent convert |
| L7/IPS policies | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | KB-guided mapping |
| App-ID mapping | N/A | Not assessed here | N/A | Config-only App-ID from the KB — no traffic wait. Log-ML write is deliberately Missing |
| Vendor rule validation | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Not assessed here | Target-specific configuration checks with findings for engineer review. |
| Security record | Clean | End of life. See Palo Alto advisory PAN-SA-2024-0010 | Clean | No credentials stored |
| Output format | FMC API | PAN-OS XML | FortiOS CLI | Targets: PAN-OS XML/SET/Panorama, FortiGate, IOS-XE, JunOS, Aruba CX. Router and switch results stay in NEEDS REVIEW. FMC is file output; Strata Cloud Manager is supported on request, not in the self-service platform. Source-only: ASA, Aruba OS, Check Point. |
The difference between converting and hoping vs. converting and proving.
Legacy tools perform a single-pass conversion, then leave you to manually verify every object, rule, and reference before deployment.
A multi-stage validation pipeline checks objects, features, references, and vendor rules independently — catching errors before they reach your network.
Every major firewall vendor offers some form of policy optimization. Most are limited to a single platform, require live traffic data, and focus on one problem at a time. Here is how the landscape looks today.
The standard App-ID adoption workflow — whether using Palo Alto's built-in Policy Optimizer, vendor professional services tools, or third-party scripts — follows a well-documented pattern: clone port-based rules with App-ID additions above the originals, then observe traffic over weeks before removing the legacy rules.
Rather than waiting for traffic to tell you which App-IDs to use, NetConverter analyzes your configuration against a comprehensive knowledge base of port-to-application mappings — delivering per-rule recommendations with confidence scoring before any changes are made.
Built-in tools and vendor scripts focus on App-ID migration. NetConverter covers the full optimization landscape.
| Capability | Policy Optimizer & Vendor Scripts | NetConverter |
|---|---|---|
| Primary purpose | App-ID adoption (single focus) | Full optimization + App-ID + posture |
| Assessment speed | Requires days-weeks of traffic data collection | Complete analysis in under 2 minutes |
| App-ID intelligence | Based on observed traffic patterns | Knowledge-backed, works without traffic data |
| Confidence scoring | Application count and hitcount data | Per-rule confidence % with risk classification |
| Unused object detection | Not included | Full hierarchy-aware scanning |
| Shadow rule detection | Not included | Multi-criteria analysis |
| Security posture audit | Not included | Disabled rules, any-any, missing profiles |
| Duplicate detection | Not included | Cross-device-group consolidation |
| Report exports | In-product views only | Excel (14 sheets), YAML, JSON, text |
| Platforms | PAN-OS / Panorama only | Panorama, PAN-OS, Cisco FMC (collector snapshot) |
| Pre-change risk | Requires changes on production device | Read-only analysis — zero production risk |
| Works with | Existing traffic patterns only | Any config — lab, pre-production, or live |
Note: NetConverter complements the standard App-ID adoption workflow. Use NetConverter for rapid assessment and prioritization, then follow your preferred implementation approach — whether that's Policy Optimizer, professional services, or manual execution — with confidence in which rules to migrate first.
Each vendor provides built-in tools for their own platform. Third-party tools cover many vendors. NetConverter migrates and validates firewalls, routers and switches.
| Capability | PA Policy Optimizer | Cisco CDO Analyzer | FortiManager | Tufin / AlgoSec | NetConverter |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Platforms covered | PAN-OS only | FMC / FTD only | FortiGate only | Multi-vendor | Panorama, PAN-OS, Cisco FMC (collector snapshot) |
| App-ID / App migration | Yes (traffic-based) | No equivalent | No equivalent | Partial | Knowledge-backed |
| Unused object detection | No | Via community scripts | Yes (date filter) | Yes | Yes (hierarchy-aware) |
| Shadow rule detection | No | Yes | No | Yes | Yes (multi-criteria) |
| Duplicate rule detection | No | Yes | No | Yes | Yes (cross-DG) |
| Security posture audit | No | Expired rules only | No | Yes | Yes (profiles, logging, any-any) |
| Works without traffic data | No — requires production traffic | Yes | Partial | Yes | Yes — config analysis only |
| Export / remediation plan | In-product only | Recommendations only | No export | Reports + workflows | Excel, YAML, JSON, text |
| Deployment model | Built into firewall | Cloud service (CDO) | Built into FortiManager | On-prem or SaaS | SaaS — no install |
Current coverage: Palo Alto Panorama optimization is generally available. Cisco FMC environments are analyzed from the snapshot the read-only FMC collector builds (GET requests only); a raw FMC export is refused. Cisco FTD on its own, as FTD show running-config text, is a roadmap item; FTD devices managed by FMC are read through the FMC collector. NetConverter does not read Palo Alto Strata Cloud Manager or Fortinet FortiManager configurations today; FortiGate devices are analyzed from their own configurations. NetConverter reports findings and recommendations; it does not push changes to your management platform. Our goal is a single tool that analyses every vendor you manage — without needing a separate license, subscription, or workflow for each platform.
Sources: PAN-OS Policy Optimizer • Cisco Policy Analyzer & Optimizer • FortiManager Best Practices
Engineer review of NEEDS REVIEW and BLOCKED findings is required before deployment.
Checked output comes with findings. Engineer review of NEEDS REVIEW and BLOCKED findings is required before deployment.